(b) Chatam, a limited liability company, is a long-standing client. One of its subsidiarie
(b) Chatam, a limited liability company, is a long-standing client. One of its subsidiaries, Ayora, has made losses
for several years. At your firm’s request, Chatam’s management has made a written representation that goodwill
arising on the acquisition of Ayora is not impaired. Your firm’s auditor’s report on the consolidated financial
statements of Chatam for the year ended 31 March 2005 is unmodified. Your firm’s auditor’s report on the
financial statements of Ayora is similarly unmodified. Chatam’s Chief Executive, Charles Barrington, is due to
retire in 2006 when his share options mature. (6 marks)
Required:
Comment on the ethical and other professional issues raised by each of the above matters and their implications,
if any, for the continuation of each assignment.
NOTE: The mark allocation is shown against each of the three issues.
(b) Unmodified auditor’s reports
Ethical and professional issues
■ An unmodified opinion means, inter alia, that:
– there are no material matters giving rise to disagreement with the auditor; and
– the auditor’s report does not include an emphasis of matter paragraph (e.g. regarding going concern).
■ By implication the auditor must have obtained sufficient appropriate evidence that notwithstanding the losses:
– the going concern basis is appropriate to Ayora’s financial statements and any related matters (e.g. parental
support) are adequately disclosed therein;
– goodwill in Chatam’s consolidated financial statements is not materially impaired.
■ Management’s written representation (that the goodwill is not impaired) must have been necessary (otherwise it should
not have been asked for). This means that Bartolome does not have sufficient other audit evidence. This seems dubious
as management should have carried out an impairment test to satisfy themselves that goodwill is not impaired. This
test should similarly have satisfied Bartolome.
■ If there is evidence that goodwill is impaired management’s refusal to write it down might be considered a fraud.
■ The matter may cast doubt on the quality of audit evidence obtained in other areas. All other matters on which
management representations have been obtained should be reviewed by another audit partner/manager.
■ Charles Barrington is retiring next year and his share options would presumably be worth less if goodwill were written
down. His position in this long-standing client suggests a familiarity threat.
■ Bartolome may be threatened by self-interest to accept the representation as sufficient in order to retain the client.
■ Bartolome may be unduly influenced by a combination of factors (familiarity and previous experience) and failing to
exercise the necessary degree of professional scepticism.
Implications for continuation with assignment
There is no reason why the audit should not be continued. However, a change in senior audit staff and audit manager may
be overdue. The unmodified auditor’s reports should be subject to a cold review and any quality control issues raised with
the staff who conducted the audit.
设a=(√5-1)/2,求(a^5+a^4-2a^3-a^2-a+2)/a^3-a∵2a=√5-1 数学 2020-04-05 …
A:Is this your car,Jim?B:Yes.Iam cleaning the car 英语 2020-05-16 …
This is a room in Kate’s house.There is a big bed 英语 2020-05-16 …
英语例句:The price of A is more than that of B which 英语 2020-05-16 …
A/O排泥问题:arm:A/O后面有个沉淀池.排泥是只排沉淀池的泥么?如果是这样,想保证A/O的泥 物理 2020-07-07 …
一、已知数集M满足条件:若a∈M,则(1+a)/(1-a)∈M(a≠0,a≠±1)(1)若3∈M, 数学 2020-07-30 …
救命:组单词将以下字母组成国家名:s\a\a\is\a\r\s\u\le\x\o\m\i\cy\k\ 英语 2020-11-26 …
做到英文题,不会的也说两句感触!给你几个字母,请将它组成一个国家的名字!例如:a/c/i/h/nCh 语文 2020-12-31 …
试探讨方程ax=b的解的情况.当a不等于o时,方程有唯解x=b除以a,当a=o=b时,方程试探讨方程 数学 2021-01-12 …
函数f[x]=logaXa大于0,且a不等于1,在2,3上最大值为1,则a=当a大于1时,f(x)图 数学 2021-01-15 …