来看看这个同位语从句,英语周报上有这么一个句子:Someofmyclassmatesholdtheviewthatsuchactivitycangiveusmuchfunandbeingclosetonatureisgoodforourhealth.我们有两种观点:1.这个句子是对的,这是一

Question

来看看这个同位语从句,
英语周报上有这么一个句子:
Some of my classmates hold the view that such activity can give us much fun and being close to nature is good for our health.
我们有两种观点:
1.这个句子是对的,这是一个由一个that 引导的两个并列句being close to nature is good for our health 和such activity can give us much fun 作view的同位语
2.and 后面的句子要在being 前再加一个that,这样就和前面的that从句一样作并列的同位语从句解释view的内容.
到底and 后面要不要加that呢?
我个人同意第2种观点,我怀疑并列从句难道可以只有一个引导词?后面没有引导词难道不会引起误解吗?不仔细分析的话会当它和主句并列呢.
但观点1的持有者也很自信很坚持,我犹豫了,

Answer 1

分析得很有道理.从整个句子意思来看,such activity can give us much fun 和 being close to nature is good for our health 应该是作view的同位语,但是,同为语从句的引导词that一般不能省略.本句第二个同位语从句的引导词that更不能省略,以免引起误解,也就是被误解为：Some of my classmates hold the view that such activity can give us much fun.与being close to nature is good for our health.是两个并列分句.