带有确定的过去时间状语时但是对现在的影响可以用现在完成时吗?例句:MrSmith'scaronhiswaytoworkyesterday?Heislateandseemedsotired.答案是brokedown还是hasbrokendown?

Question

带有确定的过去时间状语时 但是对现在的影响 可以用现在完成时吗?
例句:Mr Smith's car ______ on his way to work yesterday? He is late and seemed so tired.
答案 是 broke down 还是has broken down?

Answer 1

第一句话就是单纯的陈述句,不用完成时.两句话你要分开来看.
第二句,he seemed so tired for his car had broken down on his way to work .