一道英语选择题,Sighs on the doors tell you ( ) to go in or out.Sighs on the doors tell you ( ) to go in or out.A.which B.where C.why D.what 谁帮我讲讲啊?我总觉得是A

Question

一道英语选择题,Sighs on the doors tell you ( ) to go in or out.
Sighs on the doors tell you ( ) to go in or out.
A.which B.where C.why D.what
谁帮我讲讲啊?我总觉得是A

Answer 1

答：此题源自下文.有打字错.signs才是标记,别叹息!
译：门上的标记可以告诉你在哪里进去或出去.
析; 本题句中的in 和out 并列,所以只能看作是副词,不是介词,不跟宾语,所以不能跟which构成动介宾关系.（你可以说go into a room,不说go in a room,可以go out of a room,不能说go out a room),而且这个which也不知道指代的是什么.
见到原文之前,对此题也有怀疑,一般说：I don't know where to go.(不说where to go in的）,所以以为题目有误,答案应为whether:如I don't know whether to go in or out.但就是这句话,也是有逻辑错误的,因为一个人在某一时刻只能处在一个地点.这个地点要么在里面,要么在外面.没有这么一个两难选择.原题中也没有这个选择项.
这个题确实出得不好.不应在没有上下文的情况下,用这个题句.
上面有人译成“从哪里进去或出去”,这个“从”,就是from,但where不包括这个from,只包含有at/in/on/to.
此句的语境是：有一幢封闭的建筑物,有门,但你不知道.所以在门上贴上门的标志,你就知道了,不会撞墙了.
33.Ways of Communication
When you speak,write a letter,or make a telephone call,your words carry a message.People communicate with words.But do you know people also communicate without words A smile on your face shows you are happy or friendly.Tears in your eyes tell others that you are sad.When you raise your hand in class,the teacher knows you want to say something or ask questions.You shake your head and people know you are saying "No".You nod and people know your are saying "Yes".
Other things can also carry messages.For example,a sign at the bus stop helps you to know which bus to take.A sign on the wall of your school helps you to find the library.Signs on the doors tell you where to go in or out.Have you ever noticed that there area lot of signs around you and that you receive messages from them all the time
People can communicate in many other ways.An artist can use his drawings to tell about beautiful mountains,the blue seas and many other things.Books are written to tell you about all the wonderful things in the world and what other people are thinking about.
(204 words)
华江《英语名篇佳作100篇背诵手册》